Not all green is tophi: The importance of optimizing minimum attenuation and using a tin filter to minimize clumpy artifacts on foot and ankle dual-energy CT

OBJECTIVE: The clumpy artifact has a high misdiagnosis rate, but the artifact has not been well studied. The aims of this study were to evaluate the frequency and location of clumpy artifacts, the rate of misdiagnosis of clumpy artifacts as gout, and the effects of raising the minimum attenuation value and using a selective photon shield in dual-energy CT (DECT). MATERIALS AND METHODS: Forty patients without gout who underwent foot and ankle DECT were enrolled in this study. Images in both sets were randomly assigned a minimum attenuation of 130 HU or 150 HU. Three radiologists independently checked all images for presence, volume, and location of green color-coded pixelation and graded their findings according to a 4-point confidence scale, frequency, and volume. Misdiagnosis rate and misdiagnosis score were compared using the Wilcoxon signed rank and McNemar tests. RESULTS: In set 1, the frequency of clumpy artifacts in DECT with the minimum attenuation set to 130 HU and 150 HU were 81% and 68%, respectively. For all three readers, the misdiagnosis rate and misdiagnosis score decreased when changing the minimum attenuation from 130 HU to 150 HU. In set 2, with the minimum attenuation set to 130 HU, the frequency of the clumpy artifact was 44%; with the minimum attenuation set to 150 HU, no clumpy artifacts were seen. CONCLUSION: Clumpy artifacts occurred frequently in DECT without a tin filter. Setting the minimum attenuation to the higher value of 150 HU reduced the frequency of clumpy artifacts, and adding a tin filter to DECT greatly reduced their occurrence.